Traditional Marketing Vs Digital Marketing – 7 Pros and Cons

Marketing is an essential part of a business, regardless of industry; a savvy entrepreneur not only recognizes this but also allocates funds for this activity. Marketing basically means creating awareness and publicity about your business, its products, and services, with a view to getting people to purchase them. With competition being intense and increasing with every passing day, marketing is becoming even more crucial for a business who wants to stand out from the competition.

However, in this day where so much business happens online, there could be some confusion over which approach to take: traditional marketing vs digital marketing. Often, the budget is capable of accommodating only one of the two – at least, most marketers think that way. Obviously, the best way to decide is to work out which of the two will give you maximum returns for your expenditure.

Then there is also the question of whom to entrust with the marketing – should you do it yourself, or hire an outside agency to do it for you? But before we delve into the mystifying realm of marketing, let’s revisit both these methods in some detail.

Traditional Marketing

Traditional marketing has been around for several decades – and is still very much alive. It consists of advertising through the print media, like newspapers and magazines, TV, radio, flyers, postal letters, brochures, banners, and hoardings.

Digital Marketing

This refers to the marketing activities carried out online this provides the best pros and cons between traditional marketing vs digital marketing – social media posts, ads on social networks, blogs, YouTube Videos, email marketing, pop-up ads, click bait URLs, and so on. These methods are very effective, and with every business looking to establish a robust online presence, new avenues of digital marketing are emerging every single day.

Benefits of Traditional Marketing

Reach local target audience easily:

By advertising on FM radio and local editions of newspapers, you can easily target the potential customers in a particular city. Flyers in the mail also help target specific suburbs or areas.

Save hard copies:

Your target audience can keep hard copies of your advertising material, like flyers and magazine ads, which they can go through repeatedly.

Easy to Understand:

Anyone without internet can be reached through this approach, and people understand it easier as they have been used to it for some time. A study conducted by a neuro-marketing firm in Canada showed that direct mail required 21% less cognitive power to process vis-à-vis digital advertising.

Disadvantages of Traditional Marketing

It is less engaging

It’s a more passive form of marketing, and there is very little actual engagement. It consists of providing information to the customer and hoping that they will purchase.

It is more expensive

Advertising in the newspaper, radio, and TV can be very expensive – no wonder most TV ads are just a few seconds!

Difficult to measure ROI

It is very difficult to see how successful or otherwise your marketing campaign was, as there are no numbers to measure.

Advantages of Digital Marketing

You can Target a Vast Audience

You can not only reach larger numbers of people, you can reach them regardless of their geographic location. When you post something on your Facebook page, you can reach someone who lives a couple of blocks away, or a continent away too!

Tap New Markets

Digital marketing helps you explore and tap hitherto undiscovered or untapped markets to enter.

You can tailor Content

Depending on your ideal buyer persona – age, gender, profession, income, preferences, dislikes, fears, goals etc. – you can personalize the content so that it gets their attention.

Through social media, live chat, and email, you can easily engage with your target audience, which is not possible through traditional marketing methods. Liking, sharing, commenting on social media posts, rating products and leaving reviews are the ways in which the audience can communicate with you. You need to respond promptly and professionally to keep them engaged.

It is Cost Effective

Digital marketing activities cost a whole lot less than traditional methods – even if you include paid ads, and cost of hiring an agency for marketing. This means at a fraction of the cost of traditional marketing, you can

The Target Audience Can Choose the Medium

Different audience members may choose different marketing mediums to consume – blogs, videos, emails, etc. This choice is not available in traditional methods. Often, flyers in the mailbox get crumpled and thrown away. But with digital, people have the choice to sign up and unsubscribe to marketing materials.

Instant Publicity

When you post something on YouTube or Facebook, your target audience can see it almost immediately – gaining your business instant publicity. However, in traditional methods, you have to wait; TV or radio ads are scheduled for a specific time; the reader needs to come to the newspaper ads; they have to pass the billboards on the roads to see them. But with a huge population constantly hooked on to social media, you can reach your audience much faster.

Measuring ROI is Easier:

Google Analytics and other tools help you record things like the number of people who visited your website, how many clicked on ads, how long they stayed on the website, how many purchased, and so on. This way, you can easily measure your ROI. You can see in a jiffy what worked for the business and what did not, and make the necessary changes.

Instant Results

With just a few clicks you can get all the statistics – so no more waiting to know what is happening. To give a boost to your business, all it takes is a couple of weeks, unlike traditional marketing which could take months.

Brings Everyone To The Same Level

A startup can compete with an industry giant if they have a crafty digital marketing strategy. However, this is not possible in traditional marketing. A small business would scarcely have the resources to spend on TV and print ads.

Brand Building

An awesome website with great content will go a long way in generating leads and helping conversions; similarly, engaging social media posts and creative videos will also create brand awareness, and even help build loyalty. If you give your consumers something of value, you can be sure they will keep coming back for more. With traditional marketing, only big businesses can successfully build the brand, as it is a very expensive affair.

It is Not Intrusive  

Viewers usually get annoyed when their favorite shows or sports telecasts are frequently interrupted by commercials; newspaper readers usually skim over the ads in it – unless they are looking for something specific. They did not choose these media to look at ads. However, online, customers can choose to completely ignore the ads, or can actively engage with them too. Often, online marketing – say social media posts for instance – are not overt; they are rather subtle ads. They provide the user with something of value, while advertising remains in the background.

The Possibility of Virality

The only scope for virality in traditional marketing is word of mouth publicity by customers. Have you ever seen people passing on flyers or letters they received to others? But in the online market, this scope is tremendous. A well-made video or well crafted social media post can get shared by tens of thousands of people – making it viral, and increasing the reach even further.

Suitable Across Industries

Every type of industry – education, finance, healthcare, retail, hospitality, or anything else – can benefit from digital marketing. The size of the business, or how long it has been operational is also not important when it comes to digital marketing methods.

Round The Clock Availability

Once you post something online, it is there for good, and your audience can access it whenever they want to, as per their convenience. This is not possible in the case of say TV ads, which are telecast at specific times.

Disadvantages of Digital Marketing

Negative Feedback

The main drawback of digital marketing is that negative feedback or complaints left by unhappy customers are visible to the general public – and that too could get shared quickly.

Requisite Expertise in the Field

To truly exploit the potential of digital marketing, you would need to employ someone who has the requisite expertise in the field – and they would also need to know your business well.

Regulation by Search Engines

Digital marketing is subject to regulation by search engines like ; they frequently issue guidelines as to what is acceptable and what is not. The search engine algorithms are also updated regularly, and the efforts you have put in may go waste, as you may need to make drastic changes in the strategy.

Which method should you choose?

So now that you have the advantages and disadvantages of both, which method would you choose?

For this, you need to have an exhaustive and in-depth knowledge of your business and your target customers. You need to conduct a study to see how each method may affect your business. If your target audience is the type that has limited access to digital media or does not prefer digital media, then you may do better with traditional methods. But if your target audience is permanently connected to the internet, you’ll need to stick with digital.

However, industry experts are of the opinion that neither method can be completely done away with. They recommend a judicious mix of both conventional and digital marketing activities. Now how much you need to spend on traditional methods, and how much on digital, will depend on several factors, and you may need to go about it by trial and error.

Looking for a good team for your next project?

Book a free strategy session to see if we’re a good fit.

Miko Bey

Looking to empower entrepreneurs and organisations to achieve epic slayage online.

Ready to find out more?

Get a free, same day, no-obligation quote!


We moderate comments, but I absolutely enjoy your comments and any opportunity to help your web slayage reach epic proportions. Chat to me!

Leave a Comment